How to Sew a Buttonhole Without a Buttonhole Foot: Step-by-Step Guide (2024)

This site is supported by our readers. We may earn a commission, at no cost to you, if you purchase through links.

If you want to know how to sew a buttonhole without a buttonhole foot, this is the most detailed step-by-step you will ever need.

You may not have a specific ‘buttonhole’ function on your sewing machine, or maybe you just want to create buttonholes like a pro using another method. These instructions are very clear and will help you measure and mark up the areas correctly, set up your zigzag stitch, and achieve great edges on your buttonholes.

Because all of your buttonholes will look professional in both form and function using this method, you will always be in control of your sewing.

How to Sew a Buttonhole Without a Buttonhole Foot?

You can sew a buttonhole without a buttonhole foot by following these steps.

Start by measuring the button’s diameter and adding 2mm to get the buttonhole length. Mark a straight line with seam allowances on both sides.

Set your sewing machine’s zigzag stitch to a width of 2-3 mm and length of 0.4 mm, adjusting tension for quality stitches. Align the fabric under the presser foot and sew down one side, following the marked line, then the other side.

To secure, sew bartacks at the top and bottom. Carefully cut open the buttonhole.

Ready to master this skill? Here’s how to perfect each step.

Measuring and Marking

First, take your ruler and measure the diameter of your button, then add 2mm to that measurement to get your length.

Use a marking tool clear to your fabric type to draw a straight line for the buttonhole on your fabric. Add on either side your seam allowance.

Mark end line placements top and bottom, creating a perpendicular "I" shape. Make your markings accurate, since it will serve as your guide in making up your buttonhole pattern.

Markings are going to help you have accurate stitches and give you guidance along the sewing process. Buttonholes have to be matched exactly with the size of a button to give a neat finish. Much of the battle with sewing is won in the preparation.

Setting Zigzag Stitch

Now that you have marked your buttonhole, it’s time to your sewing machine. First, set the zigzag width to about 2-3 mm and the length to about 0.4 mm. The settings provide a very tight, secure zigzag that goes well with buttonhole stitches.

Test these settings on a scrap piece of fabric for you to acquire a feel for the tension of your stitch required in making fine stitches. Adjust the tension if the stitches look too loose or too tight.

Always keep both the center line of the buttonhole and the middle of the presser foot aligned. Proper stitch settings wouldn’t only make your buttonhole strong but at the same time, pretty, thus providing you confidence in stitching.

Initiating Side Zigzag Stitches

After setting the zigzag stitch, you’re ready to initiate the side stitches for your buttonhole. Start by choosing a suitable fabric and ensuring you’ve selected the correct needle size and thread color. Position your fabric under the presser foot, aligning the center line with the needle.

Adjust your presser foot pressure to allow smooth movement. Begin stitching along one side of the marked buttonhole, setting the stitch length to create a tight, neat satin stitch.

Pay attention to spacing, keeping your stitches consistent for a professional look. Maintain control over the buttonhole orientation as you sew. Fray check can be applied post-stitching to prevent any thread unraveling. Repeat on the other side, ensuring symmetry.

Sewing the Buttonhole Edges

Now that you’ve initiated the side zigzag stitches, it’s time to sew the buttonhole edges. This is where the magic happens!

First, make sure your needle is centered over the marked line. Gently guide the fabric as you sew, keeping the line centered under the presser foot. Apply just enough pressure to control the fabric without stretching or distorting it.

Next, sew down one side of the buttonhole, following the marked line. Maintain an even, consistent stitch length and width. When you reach the end, turn the fabric and sew back up the other side.

The key is to keep the stitching parallel and evenly spaced. Take your time and focus on maintaining a steady pace and tension.

Securing Bar Tacks

To attach the bar tacks onto your buttonhole, set your sewing machine to a bartack stitch. Making sure that there’s balanced zigzag stitch tension will yield a strong bar tack. Adjust the length of your stitch to approximately 0.4 mm and width to 2-3 mm.

Make sure to check that your needle is sharp; this will have to be appropriate for your fabric thickness. Sew from the top of the buttonhole down the center with a zigzag, making a bar tack.

Then go to the bottom and do another one. Use a seam ripper and carefully open up the buttonhole between the two bar tacks, being very careful not to cut the stitches. This reinforces it and allows you to nicely finish your buttonhole.

Alternative Options for Foot

Not having a buttonhole foot? No big deal! You’ve got other options. Go on and try to guide your sewing with these alternatives for the Buttonhole Sewing Foot:

• Cardboard Template: Cut a cardboard template of your desired buttonhole size. Press it on your fabric for precise stitching.
• Needle and Thread: Hand-sew the buttonhole. Mark out the area of the buttonhole, then stitch by hand, making your stitches very small and quite tight.
• Awl and Chisel: Using an awl and chisel, cut the buttonhole. This gives a clean edge to the hole, especially in thick fabrics.

These, of course, are methods by which you’ll get professional-looking buttonholes without that expensive piece of equipment. Remember, practice makes perfect, so don’t be scared to play around first with scrap fabric to find out what works best for you and your project.

Using Basic Sewing Machine

Using a basic sewing machine to sew a buttonhole without a specialized foot is entirely possible. Start by setting your machine to the widest zigzag stitch and adjusting the length to zero. This initial stitch will create the bartacks at the top and bottom of your buttonhole.

Stitch Setting	Stitch Length	Stitch Width
Bartack	0	5.5
Zigzag	0.3	2

Position the fabric under the presser foot, aligning the center line with the needle. Sew up one side, turn the fabric, and sew down the other side. Finish with bartacks at each end. Use a buttonhole cutter or seam ripper to carefully open the center. With a little practice, you’ll be sewing professional-looking buttonholes on your basic machine.

Creating the Buttonhole Pattern

First, making a buttonhole pattern is about accuracy. Place lines accurately first. Take the diameter of your button, add 2 mm to it, and draw the central line on your fabric, marking it precisely. The suitability of the fabric is important: the chosen material shouldn’t fray too much.

**Some key tips:

Draw clearly with a pencil or washable marker; this will give clear lines but they’ll be temporary.

-Back wrong side with iron-on interfacing for stability.

• Check measurements again before starting a buttonhole to ensure centers are aligned properly.

It wastes less time when troubleshooting for misalignment early on. In fact, the entire sewing process goes much more smoothly if your lines are straight and in place; this, in turn, shall make making buttonholes without a buttonhole foot easier.

Hand Sewing Variation

After creating your buttonhole pattern, it’s time to explore hand sewing. Start with the right needle size and thread thickness suited to your fabric. For instance, a size 9 needle with medium-weight thread works well for most materials. First, mark your buttonhole placement carefully using a fabric pencil or chalk to prevent fabric fraying.

Initiate by making tiny, consistent stitches along the drawn lines, ensuring they’re close but not overlapping. Use a simple backstitch along the buttonhole’s length, then reinforce with a whip stitch around the edges. This hand stitching technique keeps the buttonhole durable and neat. Maintain even tension throughout to avoid puckering, ensuring your buttonhole looks professional and functions smoothly.

Finishing the Buttonhole

Now that you’ve sewn your buttonhole, it’s time to cut it open. Using a sharp pair of scissors or a buttonhole cutter, carefully cut directly down the marked center line, taking care not to snip past the end stitches. This opens the buttonhole for you.

Now it’s time to check your work. Be sure that all stitches are of similar size and that the size of the hole tallies well with the button size. Use a needle and thread to tie off loose threads or make small adjustments in the stitching if necessary.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)